| Name | Title | Date Appointed |
|---|---|---|
| Samuel Dow | Postmaster | 09/25/1801 |
| Elisha Southwick | Postmaster | 07/01/1805 *July 1, 1805 is the date of Elisha Southwick’s first financial return; his appointment date is unknown. |
| Jesse Lapham | Postmaster | 07/15/1811 |
| Augustus Mulford | Postmaster | 12/31/1814 |
| David Young | Postmaster | 06/10/1818 |
| Bradford Barns | Postmaster | 04/24/1820 |
| Seneca Hit | Postmaster | 07/20/1824 |
| Adin H. Green | Postmaster | 01/06/1827 |
| Joseph R. Green | Postmaster | 05/14/1840 |
| Aaron R. Vail | Postmaster | 05/28/1841 |
| Joseph R. Green | Postmaster | 07/29/1845 |
| Aaron R. Vail | Postmaster | 03/23/1849 |
| Andrus Eggleston | Postmaster | 06/23/1853 |
| Silas L. Griffith | Postmaster | 05/07/1860 |
| Charles M. Bruce | Postmaster | 12/18/1861 |
| James Fish | Postmaster | 09/20/1869 |
| Julius C. Griffith | Postmaster | 10/01/1873 |
| Oscar A. Adams | Postmaster | 07/16/1885 |
| William H. Bond | Postmaster | 11/25/1885 |
| William B. Griffith | Postmaster | 07/27/1889 |
| William H. Bond | Postmaster | 03/30/1893 |
| Edward J. Read | Postmaster | 04/27/1897 |
| Mrs. Glennie C. McIntyre | Postmaster | 12/08/1914 |
| Edward Patrick Kelley | Acting Postmaster | 07/31/1937 |
| Edward Patrick Kelley | Postmaster | 12/18/1937 |
| John B. Griffith | Acting Postmaster | 10/03/1955 |
| Gordon F. W. Eaves | Postmaster | 05/16/1957 |
| Mrs. Theresa D. Landon | Officer-In-Charge | 04/10/1970 |
| Mrs. Theresa D. Landon | Postmaster | 04/15/1972 |
| Brent C. Chamberlin | Officer-In-Charge | 10/14/1988 |
| Patricia A. Perkins | Postmaster | 02/25/1989 |
| Torsten Torstenson | Officer-In-Charge | 06/23/1992 |
| Lee Perry | Officer-In-Charge | 09/22/1992 |
| Lisa S. Bassett | Postmaster | 02/06/1993 |
| Sylvia S. Eugair | Officer-In-Charge | 06/19/1996 |
| William M. Campbell III | Officer-In-Charge | 01/16/1997 |
| Henry Kwiatkowski | Officer-In-Charge | 05/13/1997 |
| Margo E. Stone | Officer-In-Charge | 07/08/1997 |
| Mildred M. Shook | Postmaster | 10/22/1997 |
| Sherry Bourne | Officer-In-Charge | 12/14/2002 |
| Margo W. Stone | Postmaster | 05/17/2003 |
| Jeremy Ward | Officer-In-Charge | 11/14/2013 |
| Jacquelyn P. Sprague | Officer-In-Charge | 05/29/2014 |
On June 28, 2014, converted to a Level 6 (6-hour) Remotely Managed Post Office under the direction of the Postmaster of the Dorset Post Office. The Postmaster position remained until ultimately vacated.